This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Your Scholarly Letter November 19th 2026

If this email forwarded to you, sign up to receive weekly letters for the examined intellectual life.

All previous editions of The Letter are available on our website.

I did my research

— Written by San Choudhury

“I’ve done my research,” and “Do your own research” have become ubiquitous phrases in our contemporary discourse. While the former is usually mobilised as a badge of intellectual independence and critical thought, as was demonstrated by Taylor Swift during the 2024 US presidential election, the latter — commonly abbreviated to DYOR — is frequently deployed as a way to shift the burden of proof onto the recipient of information, serving as a convenient tactic for evading the responsibility to provide evidence and reasoned, logical argumentation. At a time when intellectual pursuits increasingly become something of a lifestyle brand, and society appears to be trading Dior for DYOR, adopting the posture of the self-made researcher has become a fashionable form of intellectual couture. It offers a convenient way of cultivating a particular intellectual identity, one that distinguishes its wearer from the masses supposedly raised on a diet of intellectual junk.

Actual professional researchers are understandably upset about this. On Reddit, I came across a post titled the ‘best response to do your own research’: 

The above is the typical retort against your everyday Joe making claims about having done their research. “Googling something is not the same as doing research”, “asking ChatGPT questions and reading the answers it gives you is not research”, “reading AI-generated summaries and overviews of topics is not research”, and neither is scrolling through partisan social media feeds or reading confirmation-biased blogs. These are ways of seeking, accessing, and consuming information — information that is naturally of varying quality. But they are not, in themselves, equivalent to conducting scientific research as practiced by actual researchers. For professional researchers, research involves a systematic process of inquiry: critically engaging with existing knowledge, identifying and refining a research question, developing an appropriate approach to investigating it, and subjecting one's emerging ideas and findings to careful scrutiny through observation, experimentation, interpretation, or other forms of analysis. The average person claiming to do research is unlikely to have subjected their inquiries to this kind of rigour. 

While I do not disagree with the distinction between ‘actual research’ and popular practices of ‘doing your own research’, I suspect that the anger and distaste professional researchers feel when confronted with such claims is not simply down to the absence of methodological rigour. I believe there is a more personal aspect to their vexation. 

Academic institutions are notoriously bad at teaching their graduates how to actually do research. Even during doctoral programmes, typically considered the highest level of formal research training, the research process remains largely black-boxed. The ultimate objective of these programmes is to transform individuals into independent researchers. However, this ‘independence’ often begins far too early. Doctoral students are frequently left to their own devices from the very beginning, expected to figure out how to do research largely on their own. Nike’s famous ‘Just Do It’ slogan might as well be the unofficial maxim governing  academia’s approach to training society’s professional researchers. “You’re here to learn how to do research, so just do it.” I do not dispute that learning through doing has its merits, especially when it comes to research, where every project is different, requiring its own combination of approaches, methods, practices, and perspectives. At the same time, I believe we can also agree that there are foundational aspects of scientific inquiry that cut across disciplinary and methodological differences: asking good questions, engaging critically with existing literature, evaluating evidence, understanding different kinds of data, and recognising the philosophical assumptions that underpin our methodological choices. These are things that can, and surely ought to, be taught more explicitly. Yet for many doctoral students, they remain something of a mystery. They spend years struggling with questions about how to formulate a good research question, how to choose a methodology consistent with their philosophical assumptions, how to interpret their findings, and how to judge whether what they have produced even constitutes a contribution to knowledge. What’s more is that even after years of learning through doing, many remain uncertain about whether they've done any of this correctly. 

Become a Paid Reader — If you like it, support it!

We are independent scholars, and we love writing this newsletter, but it’s only possible because a minority of our readers pay for it. The reading, the books, the writing, the editing, the archiving, and the work of publishing and growing The Scholarly Letter all take time.

We try to keep as many of our essays free to read as possible because we believe they make an important contribution to public scholarship. We’d love it if you came on board as a paid member. $3.99 a month gets you full access to the archive and every future post.

There is also the matter of the perceived legitimacy of claiming to be a researcher. For those who know what research entails, the right to call oneself a researcher is often associated with something that has to be earned. PhD students who have conducted actual research often struggle to self-identify as researchers. They shy away from applying the term to themselves because they question whether they really have actually earned it, whether they have gone through all the necessary rites of passage. Even when they have, many are so riddled with imposter syndrome that they struggle to believe they have produced anything worthy of even being classified as research. 

Herein lies two ironies. The first is that those who have followed recognised, formal routes to becoming researchers, often find themselves confronting the fact that much of the education they were supposed to receive about doing research has been left to informal, often solitary processes of trial and error. Even after conducting research themselves, the process remains mysterious to them. The second is that those who have dedicated themselves to developing the skills, knowledge, and intellectual discipline required to become researchers can be among the least confident in claiming the intellectual authority associated with it. Meanwhile, those with considerably less experience are remarkably confident in theirs. In effect, we get an intellectual landscape where those who have spent years learning how to do research, question whether they’re doing it correctly, and struggle to convince themselves that they’ve earned the right to call themselves a researcher, while someone else who has undergone none of this training, invested a fraction of the time, and wrestled with few (perhaps none) of the same uncertainties, says “I've done my research”. Is it really surprising, then, that actual researchers are irritated when someone who has watched a few YouTube videos and started a conversation with ChatGPT says with confidence of a kind that is unlikely to ever materialise within academia itself that they've done their research?

Of course, claiming to have done research is not quite the same thing as claiming to be a researcher. But I suspect that what irritates professional researchers is that the former can carry with it some of the intellectual authority associated with the latter. Saying ‘I've done my research’ is not just a description of having looked something up. It can also be a declaration of epistemic authority: that one has independently investigated a matter, critically evaluated the evidence, and arrived at a conclusion that deserves to be taken seriously. When such authority is claimed so casually, you can understand why our professional researchers might feel a bit aggrieved.

While I am sympathetic with the frustrations of my professional research colleagues, I am also wary of concluding that research should remain the exclusive preserve of the professional researcher class, or that we should discourage the public from pursuing their own inquiries. 

In reading about the Enlightenment and the intellectual culture that took shape in the centuries that followed, including the classical fiction written during this period, I am always struck by the enthusiasm with which people outside scientific institutions participated in scientific life. They read scientific periodicals, discussed new discoveries, attended public demonstrations, and even conducted experiments of their own. No doubt, participation in science was far from universal. But the idea of people outside of scientific institutions taking a genuine interest in scientific inquiry is one I am very much taken by. So when I see a growing enthusiasm for research outside academic institutions today, I don't instinctively see it as something to be discouraged. To me it signals the prospect of cultivating a genuine scientific society. 

That being said, I fear that such a society will remain little more than a fantasy unless we take the education of research much more seriously. If the very institutions responsible for training society's professional researchers struggle to teach the foundations of scientific inquiry, leaving even those who have undergone years of formal training uncertain about what doing research actually entails, how can we reasonably expect the wider public to develop a meaningful understanding of it? There is a considerable educational gap surrounding the practice of scientific research, one that extends well beyond the walls of academia but, rather ironically, persists within them too. Addressing this gap requires us to think much more seriously about how research is taught, both within our formal institutions and beyond them.

At the same time, on an individual level, I wonder whether we, as professional researchers who might possess at least a modicum of understanding of what research entails, ought to spend a little less time raging against people who claim to have done their research, and a little more time thinking about how we might help them learn to do it well.

Did you enjoy your Letter?

Login or Subscribe to participate

If this essay stirred something, be it a question, a reflection, a story of your own, we want to hear it. Even if it’s something negative, it’s okay. The Scholarly Letter exists because we believe that intellectual life begins in conversation and communing. Respond to this email we want to hear what you have to say and share.

Spread the Word

If this essay resonated with you and you know someone else who might appreciate it, then consider forwarding it to them. It will take 2 seconds. It took San 23 hours to write this Letter.

❝

As always, thanks for reading🍎

- The Scholarly Letter Team